Back

JINSA CEO Quoted in the Forward on Ashton Carter

Ashton Carter Brings Record of Friendship With Israel to Pentagon
Changes in Tone, Not Policy, Under New Defense Secretary

By Ron Kampeas

Washington (JTA) – Ashton Carter has championed the sale to Israel of state-of-the-art combat aircraft, has aligned himself with Iran hawks and was observed becoming misty-eyed when serenaded by Israeli soldiers.

Carter, 60, President Obama’s secretary of defense nominee, has been depicted in the media as the un-Chuck Hagel.


Ashton Carter Brings Record of Friendship With Israel to Pentagon
Changes in Tone, Not Policy, Under New Defense Secretary

By Ron Kampeas

Washington (JTA) – Ashton Carter has championed the sale to Israel of state-of-the-art combat aircraft, has aligned himself with Iran hawks and was observed becoming misty-eyed when serenaded by Israeli soldiers.

Carter, 60, President Obama’s secretary of defense nominee, has been depicted in the media as the un-Chuck Hagel.

He’s assertive and a bureaucratic in-fighter where Hagel, whose two-year stint as defense secretary ended this month with his forced resignation, was seen as passive and at times at sea. He’s hawkish, where Hagel, a Vietnam vet who as a GOP senator was virtually alone in his caucus in criticizing the Iraq War, was brought in by Obama to draw down U.S. military involvement overseas.

Yet on Israel policy, Carter would represent more continuity than change should he be confirmed. That’s in part because, despite diplomatic tensions between the Obama and Netanyahu governments, the security relationship remains as solid and ever – and also because Carter, until last year a deputy defense secretary, is a loyal soldier to his boss’ agenda.

“Ash Carter is a very respected guy in Washington; he should have no trouble being confirmed,” said Michael Makovsky, the CEO of the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs, who served as a senior defense official in the George W. Bush administration.

“He knows the building,” Makovsky said of Carter, using a Pentagon euphemism for an inside player.

Click here to read the full article

Publications

Iran Protests Update 2/3/26 – 2/9/26
Published on February 9, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/28/26 – 2/2/26
Published on February 2, 2026
Beyond the Water’s Edge: The Eastern Mediterranean’s Strengthening Security Axis
Published on February 2, 2026
Syria’s Internal Unrest Is Spurred by Turkish Ambitions
Published on January 29, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/21/26 – 1/27/26
Published on January 27, 2026
Syria’s Kurdish Crisis: An Overview of Escalation
Published on January 21, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/17/26 – 1/20/26
Published on January 20, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/16/26
Published on January 16, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/15/26
Published on January 15, 2026
Iran Protests Update 1/14/26
Published on January 14, 2026
European Arms Restrictions on Israel
Published on December 23, 2025
Why Turkey Cannot Be Trusted in Gaza
Published on December 14, 2025
The US Needs More Than Troops at a Syrian Airbase to Constrain ISIS, Iran
Published on December 2, 2025
Bringing Humanitarian Relief to the Druze of Syria
Published on October 23, 2025
Disrupting the Houthi-al Shabaab Alliance
Published on October 2, 2025
Fault Line: The Suwayda Crisis and Its Implications For Syria’s Future
Published on August 4, 2025
U.S.-Israel-Iran Conflict: 6/24/25 Update
Published on June 24, 2025
U.S.-Israel-Iran Conflict: 6/23/25 Update
Published on June 23, 2025
Israel’s Operation Rising Lion: 6/20/25 Update
Published on June 20, 2025
Israel’s Operation Rising Lion: 6/19/25 Update
Published on June 19, 2025
Israel’s Operation Rising Lion: 6/18/25 Update
Published on June 18, 2025
Israel’s Operation Rising Lion: 6/17/25 Update
Published on June 17, 2025
Israel’s Operation Rising Lion: 6/16/25 Update
Published on June 16, 2025
Over a Barrel
Published on May 29, 2009